Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Lana Clarkson 4/5/1962 - 2/3/2003

Lana Clarkson

In the early morning hours of February 3, 2003, Lana Clarkson was murdered by Phil Spector in his Alhambra mansion. It took two trials for Spector to be convicted on April 13, 2009. Spector was sentenced on May 29, 2009 to 19 years to life for Lana's murder.

This was the case that launched Trials & Tribulations. It's where I met Dominick Dunne, former DDA Alan Jackson and Beth Karas, all of whom became long time friends. 

To this day, when I see pictures of this beautiful, vibrant woman, I'm instantly back in front of her niche at the Hollywood Forever Cemetery, and the peaceful place where she is laid to rest. Saying a prayer today, for Lana and her family.

Rafael Martinez, Jr., Trial - Day 7, People's Testimony Continues

Exclusive T&T case coverage can be found HERE.

Day 6.......

UPDATED: 2/4 afternoon witnesses
Tuesday, February 3, 2015
Note
I've updated Day 4, Part III to include the detailed testimony of the first couple of witnesses. I've got a little but more to go before that's complete. I'm also working on the detailed testimony of Francisco Santos, for the morning of Day 5.

Observation

For the past six days of trial, I've been observing Martinez at the defense table. Every time an image is put up on the screen for the jurors, he turns around to look at the photo. Oftentimes, I see him with his right elbow resting on the arm of the chair with his fingers over his mouth.  Yesterday, I noticed that he was helping his attorney look for documents during criminalist Bruce Lyle's testimony.

There is a woman who comes to court and sits in the very back row on the right, against the wall. One day, Detective Townsend went up to her and asked her who she was and why she was here. The woman said that she often just comes into the courtrooms to listen and to pray.

I remember during the Blake trial, there was a man who came in several days a week carrying a large duffel bag.  He would fall asleep in one of the back rows. It was speculated among several of the people in the gallery that he was homeless because he smelled. I remember my first day attending the Blake trial, there was a homeless man sleeping in a niche corner, near the entrance to Van Nuys West Courthouse.

9:50 AM
I'm inside Dept V. Judge Speer just finished up with other court proceedings. Defense attorney Tom Burns is here.  Once the proceedings are over, Judge Speer leaves the bench and Mr. Burns paces in the well. DDA Akemon and his investigating officer, Detective Townsend have not arrived yet. I step outside the courtroom to publish this update.

I'm at lunch at the moment. Here's what happened during the morning session.

On the record without the jury present. It's around 10 AM. Mr. Burns argues to the judge about specifics in the prosecution opening statement.


Mr. Burns argues that the prosecution's argument, as his case is unfolding, with the 1101b testimony. I believe Burns is arguing that DDA Akemon has gone outside the bounds of what was ruled on by insinuating when Martinez is "shushed" that is when he lashes out. Mr. Burns complains about DDA Akemon calling the defendant "blood thirsty" in his opening statement.

I'm surprised this was not objected to at the time of the opening statement.

Burns tells the court that he doesn't think they should be allowed to argue this, in relation to intent. That it’s in direct violation of 1101. He goes onto say that he would like to be on the record that thsi is highly prejudicial to the defendant.

Akemon responds, "That’s part of the intent argument. ... When he’s told to shush he intends to cause harm.

Judge Speer responds, "The jurors have a responsibility to compare the similarities of the 1101 b evidence and the charged crimes. So any similarities between the two crimes should be considered by the jurors, ... and what sets him off, what his motive is."

Burns counters, "So, we’re adding now some type of motive on his part?"

I believe Judge Speer reponds, "It is showing motive. .. The 1101b isnt offered to show motive. .... They will be instructed to that proposition. ... But they will be able to compare."

Burns replies, "I understand that your honor. ... Were tyring to have them unring the bell for anything but intent. ... But counsel calls my client blood thristy, as a propensity to do something and he's going anginst the instrcution."

Judge Speer offers, "They can't decide what the intent is unless you know the facts and the details of each of the crimes."

Burns argues, "I have no problem with that your honor. ... My problem is the prosecuiton arguing a propensity argument."

Judge Speer assures the defense, "I won’t let the pople aruges propensity in that [way? context?]."

I'm not sure who says this next sentence. "Not that the defendant has the propensity to kill, when people shush him."

Judge Speer mentions the motive is when he's high or when he wants drugs.

Burns continues to argue, "I don’ think that argument is proper."

Judge Speer says she won't let the people argue in those terms, but [argue?] the similarity between both crimes.

Argument is finished. I have in my mind that DDA Akemon responded but I missed getting his counter.

The jury is brought in. A witness is taken out of order. People's witness, Bruce Lyle retakes the stand to reopen cross examination.  Lyle tells the jury and the court that he was mistaken how he packaged the fingernail clippings and the fingernail scrapings. Lyle now states that all the fingernails for the left hand were put in a single bindle. The same for the right hand. He doesn't remember how he packaged the fingernail scrapings. Judge Speer is not confused as to how this evidence was collected.

The witness explains that at some point in time, he knows he collected evidence in the manner he originally testified but he's not sure when that change in procedure happened.

The defense asks him if 1997 was a long, long time ago. The witness agrees. The defense asks if DNA testing back then was different than it is today. The witness agrees. DNA testing is more sensitive now. The witness agrees that there is more concern today about contamination.

DDA Akemon recrosses the witness.

DA: When you collect scrapings and clippings, even back in 1997, you maintain a chain of custody? Even with blood type evidence, etc?
BL: Correct.

The witness is excused.

Two more witness were called in the morning session.

STEVEN KORDAK, was a friend of the Boehms. He grew up in the Boehm neighborhood and knew Shawn all throughout his childhood. He testified that around 11:00 am on September 19th, 1997, he saw Shawn on the street and they exchanged greetings.

SUSAN RINEHART, LAPD Criminalist, who testified yesterday afternoon retakes the stand on direct.  When we broke for lunch, she was under cross examination.

UPDATE: 2/4 -Afternoon session witnesses
SUSAN RINEHART - LAPD criminalist retakes the stand. The defense introduces over 50 crime scene photos to document the messy home as well as what was found in the back room where Nancy conducted her drug transactions.

JESSICA STOCKTON - 36 year old, Friend of victims Nancy and Shawn and former heroin addict. She's been clean for 7-8 years. Knew Nancy through her father, who worked at the Palimono night club. Lived at the residence for a few months in 1997 just prior to their deaths. Nancy was like a mother figure to her. Testified about Nancy's personality, Shawn's mental capacity, the security procedures of the house and what she observedas far as customers coming and going. When talking about Nancy and Shawn, she became emotional on the stand. On cross examination she stated that at that time she was a dancer. Defense also asked if the work was strenuous.

At the end of the court day, the jury was ordered back for 9:30 AM.

More detailed testimony will come....
Day 8.....

Monday, February 2, 2015

Rafael Martinez, Jr., Trial - Day 6 People's Testimony Continues

Exclusive T&T coverage can be found HERE.

Day 5.........

UPDATED 6:25 PM update of the afternoon session below
Monday, February 2, 2015
Before I talk about this morning, I'd like to give a recap of the witnesses who testified Friday afternoon.

Friday Afternoon
People's witness #5, Francisco Santos was back on the stand under detailed cross examination. Santos was questioned on differences in his testimony today, and his testimony at Martinez' preliminary hearing in the 2001 case. One of the issues the defense cross examined Santos on is the blood that was found in the bathroom. Santos testified that after the attack, he never went back into the bathroom.  On other statements under cross, specifically about whether or not Martinez bought drugs on credit, the defense played Mr. Santos' statement to police to impeach his testimony today. Mr Santos, appearing a bit flustered at this point, countered, "What does that have to do with anything?" Mr. Burns commented, "I wish I could answer that." After that comment, I have the following testimony:

FS: I made have changed a few things at the beginning. I was actually scared. whether I  was going to get charged with [selling drugs].
TB: You mean [you] said things that weren't true?
FS: If you want to look at it that way.
TB: Did you say things that were not true?

FS:  I might have changed a few things. ... The fact was that [it? the attack?] happened.

#6 Richard Householder
- LAPD officer in 1997. Assisted in the 1997 Boehm investigation. Interviewed Martinez at the North Hollywood police station. Martinez told Householder that he knew the family and went to school with Shawn and his sister. He spoke to Nancy daily and saw her a week before.

#7 Martin Pinner - LAPD Detective. Assisted in the 2001 investigation into Nieves and Santos stabbings. Pinner is used to introduce the interview tape of Martinez about the stabbings. The tape is played for the jury.  The tape is long and I believe the transcript of the tape is 150 pages long.  Large binders are passed out to the witness, each juror and I believe, the court.  When 4:00 pm arrives, the tape is stopped and court will continue at 10 AM on Monday.

Monday, Feb 2, Morning Session
I arrived in Dept. V just in time. The jurors were still out in the hallway. After I get settled in my seat, DDA Akemon asks if I watched the game. I have to admit that Mr. Sprocket and I are not big sports fans. We didn't watch the game, but our neighbors across the street had a big party with lots of guests who watched the game.

After the jurors are brought in, Judge Speer addressed the jury and asks, "Who was happy with the outcome of the Super Bowl?"  One juror raised their hand.  She then asks him, "Who enjoyed the commercials?"  Two jurors.

#7 Martin Pinner
We continued with Detective Pinner and the playing of the 2001 interview with the defendant. Throughout the entire interview, Martinez insisted that Nellie [Luz Nieves] got a knife from the kitchen and stabbed him. He denied ever having control of the knife. He was not aware of any injuries on Nieves and Santos. After repeated questioning, he admitted that, in the struggle it was a possibility that he got the knife when struggling with Nieves. He admitted that it was possible that he got a potato peeler away from Santos in his struggle with Santos. At one point, he did say that he got the potato peeler.

Detective Pinner testified that this morning, he drove in his car and measured the distance between Martinez home and the victim's homes.  The distance to Nieves and Santos' homes was 1/2 mile. It took him two minutes to drive the route.  The distance from Martinez home to the Boehm home was .70 miles, or three quarters of a mile. It took him three minutes to make the drive.

Detective Pinner was cross examined on what he remembered about the 2001 investigation and if he recalled the injuries that Martinez had when he was being interviewed. Pinner was asked if a gun or BB gun was recovered from the victim's apartment.  Pinner testified that bullets were recovered but no weapons.

#8 David Riemen - LAPD officer. He testifies in uniform. On September 20, 1997, he was working North Hollywood Patrol. Riemen is currently a Sargent, in charge of facilities management. Riemen does not have a specific recollection of his work at the Boehm murder scene. In reviewing the case documents, Riemen believes that he was involved in securing the crime scene. Riemen filled out a field interview card on the defendant the following day, Sept. 21. Field interview cards are cards that are filled out by officers when they attempt to interview individuals. The field interview card that Riemen filled out is People's exhibit #20.

Rieman explains all the information on the card, Martinez description, his DL and contact numbers. A short amount of information that Martinez gave to Riemen is on the card.

Close family friend. Last seen 1 wk ago. Last spoke to on the phone Mon or Tues or Wed. Since then no response. Supposed to go to the fair 9/2097.

Sargent Rieman was under cross examination when the lunch break was called. Jurors are to return at 1:40 PM.

UPDATE 6:30 PM 
Monday, Afternoon Session
1:45 PM Judge Speer calls for the jurors.

Sgt. Reimen continued with cross examination in the afternoon. Sgt. Reimen continued to state that he did not remember the specific incident.  On redirect, Sgt. Reimen, after reviewing all the field interview cards states that he did interview more people. It appears his interviews were going door to door, and not observers on the street. In interviewing Martinez, he did not note anything about a bicycle nor did he notice any scratches or injuries on the defendant. The card indicates that Martinez told Sgt. Reimen that his nickname was "Jay" and that he was a self-employed stunt man.

#9 Bruce Lyle - Deputy Coroner Investigator, Los Angeles County. Lyle currently works for the Orange County Coroner's office as the Assistant Chief Deputy Coroner. He is not a medical doctor. His current position is administrative.

On September 20, 1997, Lyle responded to the Boehm's residence as a Coroner's Investigator. A coroner's investigator is a person that responds to a sudden violence and unexplained death. They examine the body at the scene, writes reports and takes certain types of evidence. They locate the next of kin and secure any property evidence. He goes to the scene where there might be a body and transports the body back to the coroner's. In his career, he has rolled out to over 20,000 dead body scenes.

Lyle responded to the scene with an assistant who drove the vehicle and help recover the bodies. Lyle is asked to explain his procedure for collecting bodies at the time.  They would place the decedent on a clean plastic sheet and wrap the sheet up and around the feet and head. They would then placed that in a regular clean cotton bed sheet then wrap up the body with ties around the upper body, arms and legs then tie those off.

Lyle recoverd Nancy and Shawn's bodies. They were placed in the same transport van and taken to the coroner's office. There, the bodies were placed on clean gurneys and put in the refrigerator. The next day, his next shift he collected fingernail scrapings and fingernail clippings from Nancy and Shawn.

Lyle does not remember this case and had to refer to the report he wrote. Lyle testified as to what his normal custom and practice was, since he did not remember this specific case.

There were quite a few questions on direct and cross about his procedure in collecting the fingernail scrapings and fingernail clippings. My understanding of his testimony was, [after Judge Speer questioned him about the collection] he used a standard fingernail kit that came with specific envelopes and "paper bindles" to collect the material from each hand. A left hand kit and a right hand kit. The kit for each hand came with two envelopes and a wood scraper for each hand. It was not clear to me if the fingernail kits also contained their own nail clippers, or if that was a tool he kept as part of his evidence collection kit. Lyle testified that they are not special nail clippers, but just like you might buy at Rite Aid [a local drug store chain]. After every use, the clippers are wiped down with an alcohol swab.

He would start with one hand and collect the nail clippings from that one hand. Each clipped nail was placed in a separate paper bindle. Those five paper bindles were placed in a single envelope and that envelope marked. The same procedure would be repeated for the other hand.

After the nails were clipped, then he would move onto scraping under the fingernails on the victim's hands. He would start with one hand and use the wood stick that came with the kit to scrape under the nails. Each nail scraping was dropped in its own paper bindle. Those five paper bindles were placed in an envelope and marked. The stick is thrown away. Then the procedure is repeated on the nails of the other hand.

Lyle states that it was part of his normal custom and procedure to bag the hands. He doesn't remember what he did, but he assumes he followed the procedures in effect in 1997.

During cross examination the defense put up close up photos of Nancy's hands.  The photos show her hands were covered in blood. Lyle describes rigor mortis,  lividity and signs of decomposition for the jurors and if they were present in Nancy and Shawn.

Lyle collected a human tooth to the left of Nancy's body, indicating she suffered some trauma to her face.

The witness was extensively questioned on his procedure, what he remembered and what was his normal practice at the time.

10 Susan Rinehart - LAPD Science Investigation Division Criminalist. Criminalist for SID for over 20 years. For the past 17 years, she is a DNA analyst. In September 1997, she responded to the crime scene to document and collect evidence. She gives her CV and training in criminalistics.

Through a continuing series of photographs and diagrams, DDA Akemon takes the witness through the crime scene and what she documented. She describes the photos taken outside the home, and in various rooms of the home, as well as the victim's bodies and their orientation within the rooms. It's clear from the photographs that the Boehm residence was very cluttered, packed with stuff. One could easily call the home similar to a hoarder's home. Literally every room was over loaded with items. The most normal looking room was the bathroom.

The witness is presented with photos of Shawn as he was found.  Next, we are shown photos of Nancy as she was found with lots of paper, bags and purses piled on top of her body. Rinehart describes the procedure to remove all of this debris off of Nancy.

Everything was first photographed in place with standard placard markers before it was removed, layer by layer. A sequence of photos are shown with numbered placards on items that might contain physical evidence such as fingerprints, etc. Once the first layer is removed, new placard numbers are placed on the items below and the entire scene is photographed again. This is repeated. I note the placard numbers on items in the last photo are in the 20's.

When the clock hit's 4:00 PM, Judge Speer calls an end of the court day. The witness will be back on the stand tomorrow morning at 10:00 AM.

Continued on Day 7.......