We have another guest post from T&T contributor David in Tennessee!
Judge Rejects New Trial for Lemaricus Davidson in Christian-Newsom Torture-Murder Case
On Friday, November 8, 2019, Judge Walter Kurtz turned down a bid for a new trial by Lemaricus Davidson in the January 2007 murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom.
Davidson has been considered all along as the ringleader and prime mover of the crimes.
"But Kurtz ruled Friday that killer George Thomas' claim that Davidson had no role in Newsom's death was suspect and not enough to merit either a new trial or a new sentencing hearing."
Judge Kurtz decided "the newly presented facts related to Mr. Davidson's role in the death of Christopher Newsom would not have affected the guilty verdicts in this case nor the imposition of the death penalty."
Davidson's attorneys contended Thomas' testimony at the August trial made Boyd responsible for Newsom's murder with Davidson not involved.
Judge Kurtz ruled Davidson was a central figure in the crimes with "... an active and prominent role in the commission of the crimes for which he was convicted."
In other words, the Judge considered the totality of the evidence.
Thomas had taken a secret deal to testify against Boyd. For doing so his sentence would be reduced from Life Without Parole to 50 years. He put the blame for the rape-murder of Newsom on Eric Boyd.
Kurtz didn't believe a lot of what Thomas said. Why? "The court has difficulty in crediting all of Mr. Thomas's testimony given the court's knowledge of his role in these crimes," Kurtz wrote.
A major point is that even in his putting blame on Boyd, Thomas gave still more proof of Davidson being the ringleader of the crimes.
"The court accredits Mr. Thomas's testimony that Mr. Davidson ordered the killing of Mr. Newsom, and that Boyd was the person who killed Mr. Newsom and (set his body afire)."
The full details of the crime are told in earlier articles at Trials and Tribulations.
In his 2009 trial, Davidson claimed that Christian and Newsom weren't kidnapping victims but had come to his house to buy drugs. Davidson claimed the killings happened while he was out selling drugs.
All five suspects claimed to have seen and heard nothing, either stoned, asleep, frightened, etc.
When Davidson and attorneys learned of Thomas's deal, they tried to use it to their advantage. This, despite Thomas's testimony completely refuting Davidson's assertion the couple were willing visitors, not kidnap victims.
"Prosecutor Takisha Fitzgerald argued Thomas's testimony would have 'destroyed' Davidson's defense strategy in his 2009 trial and shouldn't be used now as a basis to attack his convictions and death sentence."
The Judge ruled Thomas's testimony did nothing to absolve Davidson's guilt. Thomas's testimony has Davidson ordering Boyd to kill Newsom and told Thomas to go with him.
Taking Thomas at face value, Boyd and Thomas left the house with Newsom under orders from Davidson.
My own view is that Davidson, Boyd, and Thomas -all three- took Christopher Newsom out to be killed. This was after Newsom had undergone horrendous torture.
Judge Kurtz based his ruling on the "totality" of the evidence. Davidson's attorneys will undoubtedly appeal the ruling.
Incidentally, when Davidson was captured, he was wearing Chris Newsom's shoes. Newsom's cap's and partially burned drivers license were found in the house in which Davidson was hiding.
Eric Boyd provided the vehicle used in the kidnapping.
Here is a video report by Knoxville's ABC affiliate.
Showing posts with label Christopher Newsom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Christopher Newsom. Show all posts
Tuesday, November 12, 2019
Christian-Newsom Torture Murders Status Update, Lemaricus Davidson New Trial Bid
Tuesday, August 13, 2019
Christian-Newsom Torture Murder - Day 6 Eric Boyd Trial
Eric Boyd, at his murder trial
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID in TENNESSEE!
NOTE: This post will be updated throughout the day. Sprocket
August 13, 2019
8:40 PM PT
On Tuesday the jury found Eric Boyd guilty for his role in the torture-murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom.
The
seven-woman, five-man jury deliberated around eight hours over two days
before returning the verdict of first degree murder along with guilty
verdicts on 36 charges in all.
The verdict
carries a life sentence with possibility of parole after 51 years for
each of the two deaths. Judge Bob McGee will determine at a sentencing
hearing on September 18 whether the two life sentences will be
consecutive or concurrent. Also, what extra punishment Boyd will receive
for the other charges, including kidnapping and rape.
Of
the other defendants, Lemaricus Davidson is on death row. Letalvis
Cobbins is serving life without parole. Vanessa Coleman is serving 35
years.
George Thomas had been serving 127
years (not up for parole until his eighties) until he agreed to testify
against Boyd in return for a 50 year sentence. With the latter, Thomas
could be up for parole in his late 60's.
Thomas'
testimony in this trial was somewhat ambiguous, but he placed Boyd at
the scene and told the jury Boyd murdered Chris Newsom.
Hugh
Newsom, father of Chris, said, "We said we would not stop until Eric
Boyd was prosecuted. There were times we wanted to give up. He'll never
be back on the streets of Knoxville to commit more crimes."
David in TN
11:10 AM PT
GUILTY! The verdicts are being read now, halfway through the 36 charges. More later tonight.
9:54 AM PT
The jury has just asked a question on aggravated robbery. It
concerns whether if Channon Christian was not hurt during the carjacking
but was later. That's the question according to the Knoxville ABC
station. The jury has been given lunch.
Knoxville
News Sentinel's Jamie Satterfield tweeted this likely meant the jury has
decided the murder counts and is going down the line (of 36).
I expect a verdict sometime today. That's been the pattern of how long deliberations lasted in previous trials.
David in TN
David in TN
Christian-Newsom Torture Murder - Day 5 Eric Boyd Trial
Christopher Newsom & Channon Christian
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID in TENNESSEE!
August 12, 2019
As Day 5 begins, the prosecution reads into the record Adrienne Mathis testimony in the 2008 federal trial of Eric Boyd.
"Mathis said Boyd, her cousin, borrowed her car (white Pontiac used by the suspects to get to the apartment complex where they carjacked the couple) on either the fifth or sixth of January."
"Mathis said she found a bag of bullets in her car."
The
state rested its case. The defense moved for the case to be dismissed
due to lack of evidence. Judge Bob McGee ruled it can go to the jury.
The defendant declined to testify. The defense rested.
ADA Phil Morton gave the closing argument to the jury. Morton
emphasized Xavier Jenkins' testimony of seeing the Pontiac Sunbird which
Boyd had provided for the drive to the apartment complex where the
victims were kidnapped. Jenkins also saw activity at the Chipman house,
Christian's car, the Pontiac Sunbird parked behind Christian's car, and
four black men in Christian's car. If there were four black men, one had
to be Boyd.
Morton mentioned Mathis'
testimony. He points out what George Thomas saw in the Pontiac. Thomas saw
Boyd bring the victims in the house, bring Newsom to the tracks.
Morton
mentions the violence inflicted on the victim's bodies, the attempt to
destroy evidence with bleach, and Boyd's DNA on the gun holster.
The
state said Boyd hid Davidson after the crimes. The state said Boyd was
the only one with transportation to fulfill plans to steal a car and
carry out the carjacking. "How are they going to get there? It's miles
away."
The state goes through all 36 charges in
order and shows the evidence on every charge. The charges are 9 counts
of first degree murder of Newsom, 9 counts of first degree murder of
Christian, two counts of especially aggravated robbery, four counts of
aggravated kidnapping and 12 counts of aggravated rape.
The
state goes over the concept of criminal responsibility, which was used
to convict Thomas twice. Then the timeline is reviewed.
Morton said of Boyd, "He set the wheels in motion, literally and figuratively for all this to happen."
Morton
said the suspects were a team who had choices in their actions. They
were a "team of rapists." And "it was there for just unimaginable
reasons, they decided to brutalize these kids. They decided to rape
these kids," Morton said.
Morton used Thomas'
account to say Boyd shot Newsom in the head. Morton explained why they
were previously unable to use Thomas' statement against Boyd.
One
suspects statement to police can't be used against another suspect
unless he takes the stand. Photos of the victims came on the screen when
Morton finished his argument.
The defense
attorney, Clinton Frazier, began by saying the acts were "disgusting"
but it was Davidson, Cobbins, Thomas, and Coleman.
Frazier pointed out none of the DNA evidence belonged to Boyd. The state proved its case against the others, but not Boyd.
Frazier
claimed Jenkins saw only silhouettes, not features. He said Thomas's
loyalty is to Cobbins, and still doesn't implicate Cobbins.
Frazier details Thomas' conflicting accounts, which "don't make sense."
Frazier
said "Don't let your anger make the decision for you." He asks the jury
to hold the state to its burdens and find Boyd not guilty.
The defendants have been skillfully defended in every trial.
Takisha Fitzgerald, who has been the lead prosecutor throughout, gave the rebuttal.
Fitzgerald
said the state had proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt. She
reviews all the evidence and said testimony corroborates it.
"Mr.
Boyd was a part of it...We ask you to hold Mr. Boyd accountable,"
Fitzgerald said. She said it took 12 years because they want to get it
right."
The judge read the instructions to the jury. Three men and one woman were excused. The final panel is seven women and five men.
The jury deliberated for two and a half hours Monday and recessed for the evening. They are to resume deliberations at 9 am.
David in TN
Saturday, August 10, 2019
Christian-Newsom Torture Murder - Day 4 Eric Boyd Trial
Eric Boyd at his murder trial
Photo Credit: knoxnews.com
UPDATE 8/11: Corrected where Jenkins workplace was in relation to crime scene house. Sprocket
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID in TENNESSEE!
August 10, 2019
I have watched the trial on live stream all four days.
Friday was the fourth day of testimony in the trial of Eric Boyd for his role in the January 2007 Christian-Newsom murders in Knoxville, Tennessee.
Boyd was indicted in 2018, 10 years after being convicted in
federal court for aiding "ringleader" Lemaricus Davidson after the
crimes.
It was long thought Boyd had provided
the vehicle used in the carjacking and was involved. There wasn't much
more evidence against George Thomas, but unlike Thomas, Boyd didn't
admit to being in the Chipman street house.
The
only testimony directly linking Boyd was by Xavier Jenkins. Jenkins worked
in a waste treatment facility in the neighborhood of the Chipman street house. Jenkins testified to seeing
four black males in a white Chevy Sunbird, which was the car Boyd
provided for use by the suspects. In every trial, defense attorneys have
tried to shake Jenkin's story but he stood firm again in this trial.
The
other witness linking Boyd to the murders was Adrienne Mathis, Boyd's cousin. She
testified in an earlier trial to loaning Boyd the Sunbird. This week,
Mathis claimed to have "amnesia" and couldn't remember. She didn't change
her story, she claimed to not remember.
More on this later.
The
first testimony of the day had to do with Davidson's phone records.
Then a friend of Boyd and Davidson gave a lively account of the two
visiting her apartment.
Forensic specialist
Jennifer Millsaps testified to a piece of Boyd's stained clothing. Although it could not be linked directly to the murders, Judge Bob McGee
allowed it in.
Here is what I wrote after seeing the medical
examiner's testimony and the photos in 2012. The testimony on Friday was
identical.
"The first photo was of Chris
Newsom's burned body lying beside the railroad tracks. His body was
blackened from about the knees up with the face unrecognizable. There
was a blindfold over his eyes which somewhat preserved them. A police
officer who was a friend of the Newsoms could recognize Chris 'because
of his eyes,'
"The other photo was of Chris Newsom's bare feet which were still tied by a belt and ligature."
"Now
came Dr. Mileusnic-Polchan's (ME) presentation concerning the rape and
murder of Channon Christian. Her body was not removed from the garbage
can until at the medical examiner's office. The can was covered by a
tarpaulin while being hauled there. Her face had been covered by a white
plastic bag and the body enclosed in several black plastic bags.
"Channon Christian was a beautiful 21-year old woman who stood five feet, eight inches, and weighed 122 pounds."
"On
the screen appeared a photo of Channon's body lying on a gurney. Her
body was still contorted in the position it was in after being 'crammed'
into the trash can. She was naked from the waste down."
"The
mouth was open. The eyes were half-closed. Her face was frozen in
horror. She had died of asphyxiation after hours of agony. The left arm
was extended upward from the elbow."
"This photo hit me like a punch."
"The next photo showed abrasion inside the lips. Her gum had been knocked loose from her teeth. A photo of her face was next."
"Then
came a photo of her genitals. It revealed tremendous trauma. She had
been kicked and beaten repeatedly in the vagina. During Davidson's
trial, a beginning female deputy DA fainted at this photo."
"The
next photo was of her anus with still more heavy bruising. It looked
like she had been clubbed, She had been raped anally, vaginally, and
sodomized."
I repeat viewers of the Court TV
live stream didn't see this. The Court TV talking heads in their Atlanta
studio could not see it.
Knoxville News
Sentinel reporter Jamie Satterfield tweeted from the courtroom "Jurors
are struggling with these images. One guy rubbed his face and kept his
head down, another rubbing his temples, lady covers her mouth, etc..."
Of Newsom, Satterfield tweeted "Savaged-that's the best way to describe what happened to Chris."
On
Friday, Dr. Mileusnic-Polchan said there was tearing, bruising and
lacerations of Newsom's anus. "That was indication of damage," she told
the courtroom. "Plus, on the inside there were some additional tears and
additional bruising."
The anal injuries occurred one to two hours before Newsom was shot, she said. She confirmed that Newsom was raped.
George Thomas' testimony this week and prior by the suspects said nothing about the horrible wounds inflicted on the victims.
The prosecution rested.
Now,
the state asked Judge McGee to allow Boyd's cousin Adrienne Mathis'
prior testimony in which she told of loaning Eric Boyd the Sunbird.
Without this testimony, the state can't connect Boyd to the Sunbird.
Prosecutor Takisha Fitzgerald asked McGee to let in prior testimony only from Boyd's 2008 federal trial.
Judge
McGee gave the state a win. He ruled Mathis was "unavailable" because
of her claimed loss of memory and will allow into evidence prior federal
testimony.
That was the end of Friday's session. Court resumes on Monday.
David in TN
Thursday, August 8, 2019
Christian-Newsom Torture Murders - Day 3 Eric Boyd Trial
Christopher Newsom & Channon Christian
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID in TENNESSEE!
August 8, 2019
Today was Day 3 of the trial of Eric Boyd for his part in the Christian-Newsom murders.
The
cross examination of George Thomas by Eric Boyd's attorney was not as
extensive as expected. Clinton Frazier, Boyd's attorney, mainly went
over Thomas' not seeming to know much of anything.
The Court TV guest commentators were disappointed the cross was short.
The
mothers of the victims, Deena Christian and Mary Newsom, took the stand
in succession. This is the eighth trial they have done so. Both told of
the last time they saw their children and the shock upon finding them
missing.
Since both were over 21, the police wouldn't look for them and Chris and Channon's friends had to search themselves.
Former
Knox County Sheriff Jimmy Jones questioned Vanessa Coleman, Letalvis
Cobbins, and George Thomas in January 2007 in Kentucky. Jones thought
Thomas was most truthful but "you never get the whole truth, ever."
Daphne
Sutton, "ringleader" Lemaricus Davidson's girlfriend, testified to
thinking there was another woman in the bathroom. The door was closed
and Sutton was kept away. While telling her to leave, Davidson gave
Sutton some of Channon's clothes. When seeing them today, Sutton cried.
This never happened before.
In
a trial I attended in 2013, I walked by Daphne Sutton while she was
sitting on the bench outside the courtroom for prospective witnesses.
She gave me quite a look.
Tomorrow (Friday),
the medical examiner will testify. The jury will see gruesome photos and
the description of the torture and death inflicted on the victims.
David in TN
David in TN
Wednesday, August 7, 2019
Christian-Newsom Torture Murders - Day 2 Eric Boyd Trial
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID in TENNESSEE
August 7, 2019
Here is a video report by Jamie Satterfield of the Knoxville News Sentinel.
August 7, 2019
Here is a video report by Jamie Satterfield of the Knoxville News Sentinel.
I
watched the testimony of George Thomas on live stream by Court TV. As
always Thomas played down his own involvement. He makes the atmosphere
inside the death house seem placid. He claims to have never heard either
victim say anything, cry out, fight back.
Thomas
now says Cobbins didn't go with him and Boyd to kill Chris Newsom.
Before he had said Davidson went with Thomas. Thomas puts all crimes
against Chris Newsom on Boyd.
Thomas' account of Newsom's death doesn't fit the way the body was found, no pants or shoes. Thomas has Newsom clothed.
A
new story. Thomas claims at one point Boyd was left in the house with
Channon Christian while he, Davidson, Cobbins, and Vanessa Coleman drove
off somewhere for a short time.
What Thomas said today doesn't fit what came out at his own (two) trials and Cobbins' 2009 trial.
Thomas
did place Boyd at the scene. The other suspects had said Boyd was
present in their police interviews, but none had in court under oath
until today.
My own opinion and most other
people who have followed the case is Boyd was far more involved in the
crime than Thomas was. The difference is Thomas admitted to being in the
Chipman Street house while Boyd didn't.
Jamie
Satterfield was interviewed on Court TV this evening. She said when
federal prosecutors tried Eric Boyd in federal court for accessory after
the fact in 2008 for hiding the "ringleader," Lemaricus Davidson, they
basically made a murder case against Boyd. He had furnished the vehicle
for the carjacking.
The feds wanted to try the whole thing themselves as a carjacking-murder which federal statutes could have allowed.
However,
the torture-murders of two attractive, likable young people outraged
the Knoxville community. The local District Attorney General's office
demanded the opportunity to try the murder case in state court.
The
local DA, according to Ms. Satterfield, wanted to be certain of winning
convictions and was afraid of possibly losing if he tried Boyd.
There
is now a different administration in the Knox County DA's office and
they filed the case. The victim's parents, especially the Newsoms who
have always believed it was Eric Boyd who raped and murdered their son
were insistent on Boyd being charged.
While
Boyd denied being in the Chipman house when interviewed by Knoxville
police, he gave considerable detail about what went on, claiming
Davidson told him.
Tomorrow, Boyd's attorney will cross examine Thomas. Prosecutor Takisha Fitzgerald will have work to do on redirect.
Eric
Boyd has the most extensive criminal past of the suspects starting very
young. Boyd was a stick-up man. He walked into convenience stores,
service stations, etc, pulled a gun and demanded the contents of the
cash register. He was also an experienced carjacker. He served several
prison sentences for these offenses. The jury won't hear about Boyd's
criminal record.
David in TN
Christian-Newsom Torture Murders - Eric Boyd Trial
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID in TENNESSEE!
This is a short update by David in TN on the Eric Boyd Trial. Sprocket
August 7, 2019
This is a short update by David in TN on the Eric Boyd Trial. Sprocket
August 7, 2019
This is a summary of the first day of testimony from the Knoxville ABC affiliate. Adrienne Mathis, Eric Boyd's cousin, had testified at
earlier trials to loaning Boyd the vehicle used in the kidnapping.
Yesterday, she claimed to "not recall" doing so.
David in TN
Note: There is a live stream of the trial at the ABC affiliate link. Sprocket
Sunday, August 4, 2019
Christian-Newsom Torture Murders - Eric Boyd Upcoming Trial
Christopher Newsom, Channon Christian
GUEST ENTRY by David in Tennessee!
ERIC BOYD UPCOMING TRIAL
Tomorrow (Monday) jury selection begins in the trial of Eric Boyd for his role in the torture-murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom in Knoxville, Tennessee on January 7, 2007.
One, Knox County Criminal Court Judge Bob McGee rejected the bid by Boyd's attorney for a jury pool outside Knox County.
Two, George Thomas, a suspect already convicted in the case and sentenced to two life terms, is on the prosecution witness list. According to the sentence, Thomas would be eligible for parole after 50 years.
Knoxville News Sentinel reporter Jamie Satterfield wrote:
"Boyd has long denied he was anywhere near the Chipman Street home when Christian and Newsom were brought there, bound, blindfolded, and gagged, after they were kidnapped while preparing to leave a North Knoxville apartment complex for a date.""Thomas, on the other hand, admitted he was inside the home and saw what was going on, but he denied any active role in any of the crimes committed against the couple. A jury twice convicted him anyway. He has exhausted most of his appeals.""It's not clear yet if the state has offered Thomas a reduction in his sentence in return for his testimony against Boyd. Newsom's parents, Hugh and Mary Newsom, had once hoped to convince another suspect--Letalvis Cobbins--to testify against Boyd, but he later refused after a plea deal fell through."
The other suspects have said Eric Boyd furnished the vehicle used in the kidnapping.
David in TN
Monday, March 4, 2019
Christian-Newsom Torture Murder Case - Update on Davidson's Appeal
Previous post can be found HERE.
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID IN TENNESSEE!
This is a guest entry by our long-time contributor David in TN. Sprocket
February 28, 2019
Oh Thursday, February 28, 2019, Judge Walter Kurtz denied Lemaricus Davidson’s bid for a new trial in the Christian-Newsom torture murder case. Because of the heavy publicity the case received locally, it would have been expected the defense would request a change of venue. In most states, this means moving a trial to another city. In Tennessee, an outside jury is brought in. For the other trials for this case, juries were bused into Knoxville from Nashville, Chattanooga, and Jackson.
Since the defense asked for a Knox County jury, and rebuffed the presiding judge when he tried to talk them into an outside Knoxville jury pool, the defense was not supposed to be able to appeal on this issue.
At the January hearing, Davidson's new legal team, who specialize in capital cases, tried to do exactly that.
"The judge shot them down."
Judge Kurtz ruled Davidson "is not entitled to the benefit of hindsight. The fact that a strategy does not work does not make the lawyer ineffective."
The judge found Davidson and his lawyers made the wrong decision on their own. Davidson's attorneys testified at the hearing they hoped jury selection would drag on and a plea bargain would result.
The jury was seated on the first attempt.
The best opinion based on legal precedent was this appeal would fail and it did.
T&T's complete coverage of the Christian-Newsom Torture Murder Case
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID IN TENNESSEE!
This is a guest entry by our long-time contributor David in TN. Sprocket
February 28, 2019
Oh Thursday, February 28, 2019, Judge Walter Kurtz denied Lemaricus Davidson’s bid for a new trial in the Christian-Newsom torture murder case. Because of the heavy publicity the case received locally, it would have been expected the defense would request a change of venue. In most states, this means moving a trial to another city. In Tennessee, an outside jury is brought in. For the other trials for this case, juries were bused into Knoxville from Nashville, Chattanooga, and Jackson.
Since the defense asked for a Knox County jury, and rebuffed the presiding judge when he tried to talk them into an outside Knoxville jury pool, the defense was not supposed to be able to appeal on this issue.
At the January hearing, Davidson's new legal team, who specialize in capital cases, tried to do exactly that.
"The judge shot them down."
Judge Kurtz ruled Davidson "is not entitled to the benefit of hindsight. The fact that a strategy does not work does not make the lawyer ineffective."
The judge found Davidson and his lawyers made the wrong decision on their own. Davidson's attorneys testified at the hearing they hoped jury selection would drag on and a plea bargain would result.
The jury was seated on the first attempt.
The best opinion based on legal precedent was this appeal would fail and it did.
T&T's complete coverage of the Christian-Newsom Torture Murder Case
Thursday, February 7, 2019
The Christian-Newsom Torture Murder Case Update
Christopher Newsom, Channon Christian
Murdered January 2007
February 7, 2019
T&T is grateful to have guest contributor David in Tennessee provide an update on the Christian- Newsom case. Sprocket.
Guest Entry by David in Tennessee
I've been following major trials going back to Manson and Patty Hearst. The Christian-Newsom torture-murders are distinguished by the sheer horror, length of time, convoluted events, twists and turns.
KnoxNews.com details the horrific events. In
January 2007, Channon Christian, 21, and boyfriend Christopher Newsom
were abducted, tortured, raped (both of them), and killed in Knoxville,
Tennessee.
Channon Christian's SUV was
abandoned by the killers after wiping it down. However, a fingerprint
was found on an envelope in the car. The AFIS database linked the print
to one Lemaricus Davidson, with an address in Knoxville. When the police
arrived, they found Channon Christian's body stuffed in a garbage can.
Eventually
five suspects were arrested. Four were tried in Knox County. One, Eric
Boyd, was tried and convicted in Federal Court. More on Boyd presently.
The
four tried in state court were convicted. The "ringleader," Davidson,
was sentenced to death. His half-brother, Letalvis Cobbins, to LWOP (life without parole). George Thomas was sentenced to life with parole after 50
years. The lone female, Vanessa Coleman, to 35 years. Thomas and
Coleman had two trials. Why? Judge Richard Baumgartner was doing drugs
and having sex with a woman who was a probationer in his court. The
other defendants didn't get new trials due to rock-solid DNA evidence
against them.
In April 2018, KnoxNews.com reports a Knox County grand jury indicted Eric Boyd, who had long been suspected as one of the perpetrators.
"The
grand jury returned a 36-count presentment March 20 against Boyd, 46,
including charges of first-degree murder, felony murder, especially
aggravated robbery, especially aggravated kidnapping, and aggravated
rape in the January 2007 case."
Authorities
previously thought they didn't have enough evidence to charge Boyd.
There wasn't DNA from Boyd (at the time) on the victims and he was
crafty enough not to admit being in the death house, unlike the others.
Boyd
did give a lot of details in his police interrogation, but claimed he
heard them from Davidson. Boyd was convicted in Federal Court of hiding
Davidson and sentenced to 18 years.
Christopher Newsom's parents had pushed for Boyd's prosecution, whom they believed raped and murdered their son.
"Two
volunteer sleuths -Tom Hyman and Kevin Cowans- have helped the Newsoms
piece together evidence to present to Knox County District Attorney
General Charme Allen."
The Knox County DAG has declined to say what new evidence resulted in the grand jury indictment.
According to a KnoxNews.com story in June 2018, Cobbins and Thomas
implicated Boyd in their interrogations, but those statements can't be
used as evidence against him. The U.S Supreme Court ruled defendants
"have the right to confront their accusers via the witness stand, not
through unchallenged statements of co-defendants."
The
witness list against Boyd indicates his own words will be used against
him, something all suspects are told. Several corrections officers and
investigators are on the witness list.
Last week KnoxNews.com reported, Lemaricus Davidson, "ringleader" of the Christian-Newsom murders, was in Knoxville for a hearing requesting a new trial.
One
of the oddities of the whole case is Davidson and his lawyers insisting
on a Knox County jury. In all the other trials, a jury was brought in
from elsewhere in Tennessee. Judge Baumgartner in open court pleaded
with them to have a jury outside of Knox County. He sighed when the
defense lawyers still insisted on it.
Eventually,
Davidson was convicted and sentenced to death. Supposedly, the defense
can't use the Knox County jury as an issue for appeal. It sounds like
they are doing just that.
Why did they call for
a local jury? The answer is the defense talked themselves into
believing 12 impartial jurors couldn't be found. And defense attorney
Doug Trant suggested in testimony at the hearing, hoped not to.
Trant said: "I told (Davidson) if we were not able to seat a jury, he could not be convicted."
The
defense attorneys hoped jury selection would be "interminable" and the
prosecution might offer Davidson a plea deal on a reduced charge. The
District Attorney General's office had offered the defense a guilty plea
to life without parole. Davidson said no, declaring he preferred death
to life in prison.
After being convicted and sentenced to death, Davidson regretted his decision.
Trant
said: "I remember when he got the death sentence, he cried. He said it
was one thing to anticipate a death sentence and another to actually get
it."
The other defense attorney, David Eldridge, complained about the "level of publicity."
The defense also said it was common knowledge in the legal community that Judge Baumgartner was a heavy user of painkillers.
Davidson's
conviction was nearly overturned because of Baumgartner's drug use on
the bench, but the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled there was no
"structural error." The defense is trying again.
Most likely, they won't succeed, but with this case, you never know.
Eric Boyd's trial is currently set for August 2019.
Sunday, January 28, 2018
Former Knox Co. Judge Richard Baumgartner Found Dead at Home
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID in TENNESSEE!
Former Knox County Judge Richard Baumgartner, 70, died on January 23. He presided over the trials of the defendants in the Christian-Newsom torture-murders covered here at T&T. Those defendants were: Letalvis Cobbins, Lemaricus Davidson, George Thomas and Vanessa Coleman.
In 2011, Baumgartner came under a criminal probe for obtaining drugs from a probationer in his drug court and was disbarred. Baumgartner was convicted of five counts of misprision of a felony. He served a brief time in prison a year later. This caused two of the four defendants (Thomas & Coleman) to be retried.
Baumgartner led the push to allow cameras in Tennessee courtrooms, his own in particular. He lobbied within the Knox County Superior Court for the Christian-Newsom case. Ironically, this led to his downfall. Baumgartner visited a woman named Deena Castleman when she was in the hospital during the trial of the crime's ringleader, at a time when everybody in Knox County with a computer was watching the live-streaming trial. People at the hospital recognized him.
Knoxville News-Sentinel reporter Jamie Satterfield wrote an excellent account in 2012 of how Baumgartner was able to stay on the Judicial bench titled "Court of Secrecy: How Richard Baumgartner stayed on the bench despite warning signs". The article has been published again.
by David in Tennessee
Judge Richard Baumgartner
On the bench; date unknown.
Former Knox County Judge Richard Baumgartner, 70, died on January 23. He presided over the trials of the defendants in the Christian-Newsom torture-murders covered here at T&T. Those defendants were: Letalvis Cobbins, Lemaricus Davidson, George Thomas and Vanessa Coleman.
Channon Christian, Christopher Newsom
In 2011, Baumgartner came under a criminal probe for obtaining drugs from a probationer in his drug court and was disbarred. Baumgartner was convicted of five counts of misprision of a felony. He served a brief time in prison a year later. This caused two of the four defendants (Thomas & Coleman) to be retried.
Baumgartner led the push to allow cameras in Tennessee courtrooms, his own in particular. He lobbied within the Knox County Superior Court for the Christian-Newsom case. Ironically, this led to his downfall. Baumgartner visited a woman named Deena Castleman when she was in the hospital during the trial of the crime's ringleader, at a time when everybody in Knox County with a computer was watching the live-streaming trial. People at the hospital recognized him.
Knoxville News-Sentinel reporter Jamie Satterfield wrote an excellent account in 2012 of how Baumgartner was able to stay on the Judicial bench titled "Court of Secrecy: How Richard Baumgartner stayed on the bench despite warning signs". The article has been published again.
by David in Tennessee
Wednesday, September 2, 2015
Christian-Newsom Murders - Long Awaited Documentary 'FOREVER CHANGED' Now Available
September 2, 2015
The long awaited film, Forever Changed, documenting the murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom, and the families journey to justice is now available for purchase.
The film, directed by Gail Witt, is available for purchase through G & W Enterprises.
Friday, December 12, 2014
Christinan Newsom Case - Vanessa Coleman Denied Parole
GUEST ENTRY FROM DAVID in TENNENNESSEE!
David brings us updates on two events related to Vanessa Coleman's second trial. Sprocket
David brings us updates on two events related to Vanessa Coleman's second trial. Sprocket
Vanessa Coleman Denied Parole
by
David In Tennessee
On
Wednesday, December 10, 2014, Vanessa Coleman was denied parole for
Facilitation of the rape-murder of Channon Christian. The
torture-murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom took place on the night of January 6-7, 2007. Coleman was convicted a second time in a retrial on November 20, 2012. Judge Blackwood sentenced her to 35 years in prison on February 1, 2013.
Why
was she up for parole so soon? Vanessa Coleman was convicted of facilitation, not murder. Since she was arrested in
January 2007 and remained in custody, Coleman is credited with nearly eight years in prison and
is eligible for parole under Tennessee law.
In a unanimous vote
after a hearing lasting 90 minutes, five members of the panel rejected
the application. One member was absent. Another was too new to the panel
to vote.
Vanessa Coleman's defense at both
trials was she was afraid of the others, one of whom was her boyfriend,
and was herself a prisoner in the death house.
A
major question throughout is why Coleman did not free Christian and
flee on two occasions when she was alone with her inside ringleader
Lemaricus Davidson's house. When questioned at the hearing, Coleman
said; "I'm currently in the appeal process, and I have spoken to my
lawyer, and it was wise for me not to speak."
Coleman's appeal was rejected by the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals a
few days before and the Tennessee Supreme Court is unlikely to even look
at the case after two trials.
The main
evidence against Coleman was a diary entry a few days after Christian
and Newsom were tortured, raped (both of them), and murdered. Coleman
wrote of her "adventure in the Big T.N," and how much "she loved her
life." When questioned about this at the hearing, Coleman answered "That
statement had nothing to do with the case, sir, and that's all I can
say."
Davidson was sentenced to death. His
brother and Coleman's boyfriend, Letalvis Cobbins, was sentenced to life
without parole. Cobbins' friend, George Thomas was sentenced to life
with possible parole after 50 years.
Here is a report from WATE, Knoxville's ABC affiliate.
Tuesday, April 15, 2014
Christian-Newsom Bills Pass Tennessee House and Senate
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID in TENNESSEE!
Christian-Newsome Bills Pass Tennessee House and Senate
The Tennessee State Senate on Thursday, February 20, passed the two bills that I previously mentioned in my last entry. They
were designed to help crime victims and their families from being
further victimized in the courts.
The parents of Channon Christian and Christopher
Newsom spoke in favor of the bills before the Tennessee State Senate
Judiciary Committee earlier in February.
Christian
and Newsom were carjacked, tortured, and murdered in 2007. The
defendants were found guilty, but because Judge Richard Baumgartner was
guilty of using illegal drugs during the trials, retrials were ordered
for two of the defendants.
Baumgartner had verbally accepted the verdicts, but
did not sign the form acting as 13th Juror upholding the jury's decision
before being forced to resign from the bench.
Senate
Bill 1796, The Chris Newsom Act, creates a presumption that the
presiding judge presumably has completed his duties upon accepting the
verdict of the jury.
Senate Bill 1797, The Channon Christian Act,
restricts bringing into evidence "presumptions or false information that
are related to the victim that is totally unrelated to the crime."
On March 27, 2014, the Tennessee House of Representatives passed the two bills unanimously. When the bills passed, members of the legislature gave a standing ovation.
The Channon Christian and Chris Newsom acts will go
to the governor's desk for signature. Governor Haslam has said he
supports both measures.
The torture-murders of
Christian and Newsom took place in the home of Lemaricus Davidson, who
was convicted of both murders and sentenced to death. The other
defendants, Letalvis Cobbins, George Thomas, and Vanessa Coleman were
convicted and sentenced to life without parole, life with the
possibility of parole, and 35 years. Thomas and Coleman were tried a
second time because of the 13th Juror rule. Davidson and Cobbins were
not retried because of DNA evidence pointing to their guilt.
A few weeks ago, Knoxville News Sentinel reporter
Jamie Satterfield, who covered the story, tweeted that she doesn't think
the Channon Christian Act was constitutional.
She may be right. The courts give a defendant a lot of leeway in defending themselves.
I emailed Satterfield several months ago and asked
how her proposed book on the Christian-Newsom case was coming along. She
never replied. I have emailed her several times over the years and
previously she always got back to me.
Two weeks ago I emailed her again with the same
question. No answer. I wonder if Jamie Satterfield has given up on
writing the book. I check her twitter feed daily and she never refers to
it. I hope I'm wrong as this is nothing but speculation on my part.
There is no news on the proposed film on the case.
Gail Witt, who was making the film, recently died of cancer. The
Facebook page, "Forever Changed,"
has reported that the film is completed and is still in the editing
stage.
David in TN
Wednesday, February 12, 2014
Christian Newsom Murders: Parents Speak Before Tennessee Senate Judicary Committee
GUEST ENTRY by DAVID in TENNESSEE!
Parents of Channon Christian and Chris Newsom Speak Before Tennessee Senate Judiciary Committee by David In TN
On Tuesday, February 11, the
parents of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom traveled to
Nashville and appeared before the Tennessee Senate Judiciary Committee.
The committee unanimously approved two bills they said can ease some of the heartbreak they suffered in the Tennessee judicial system.
On Saturday night, January 6, 2007, Channon Christian, 21, and Christopher Newsom, 23, were carjacked, tortured, and murdered.
Four
suspects, Letalvis Cobbins, Lemaricus Davidson, George Thomas, and
Vanessa Coleman, were convicted during 2009-10. Cobbins received a
sentence of life without parole. Davidson was sentenced to death. Thomas
received life without parole and Coleman was convicted of facilitation
of the crimes against Channon Christian for a sentence of 53 years.
George Thomas and Vanessa Coleman each received a
second trial. Thomas was convicted again, but his sentence was life with
the possibility of parole after 50 years. Coleman was convicted on 13
counts, down from 17 in her first trial, resulting in a sentence of 35
years, down from 53.
I attended three of the seven trials in the
Christian-Newsom case, two sentencing hearings, and one motions hearing.
I spoke several times to Hugh Newsom, father of Chris, and heard Gary
Christian make several comments during breaks in trial.
The parents were unhappy with some of the sentences,
in particular the life sentence for Letalvis Cobbins, brother of
ringleader Lemaricus Davidson, and the sentence for the lone female
defendant, Vanessa Coleman.
When I met Hugh Newsom before Coleman's second trial
in November 2012, he told me it was because of "the idiot judge" that
the case was being retried. (The retrials were caused by the drug conviction of Judge Richard Baumgartner.) Of Judge Jon Kerry Blackwood, who replaced
Baumgartner, Mr. Newsom said "I don't like this judge either."
During the retrial last May of George Thomas, Gary Christian said he would "never, ever let anybody forget."
The first bill
was the Chris Newsom Act, which would modify Tennessee's "13th Juror"
rule. Former judge Baumgartner went through four verdicts and four
sentencing hearings without bothering to affirm the verdicts as 13th
Juror as required by Tennessee law.
Judge Blackwood overturned all four verdicts, saying
he could not act as 13th Juror without seeing testimony. After
presiding over the Coleman retrial, Blackwood affirmed the verdict as
13th Juror.
Under the new law, a judge is required to act as
13th Juror immediately after a jury's unanimous verdict. Since
Baumgartner left the bench, Knox County judges have been doing exactly
that.
Judge Walter Kurtz, who replaced Blackwood for the George
Thomas retrial, quickly acted as 13th Juror when Thomas was again
convicted. Judge Kurtz previously overturned Blackwood's ruling for
retrials and upheld the guilty verdicts for Cobbins and Davidson because
of overwhelming DNA evidence against both.
The second bill passed by the Senate committee was
the Channon Christian Act and is supposed to prevent defense attorneys
from making up stories out of whole cloth about a deceased victim. Deena
Christian, Channon's mother, said attorneys for defendant Lemaricus
Davidson "lied to everybody about our daughter," falsely claiming
Channon "had associated with Davidson and used drugs."
Her autopsy revealed Channon Christian had no drugs
in her system and she had to pass a drug test to have her job. There was
no evidence such as cell phone records that the murdered couple knew
their killers.
Both bills passed 9-0 without debate beyond sponsor
Sen. Randy McNally explaining them and senators expressing sympathy for
the families and appreciation for their testimony.
Mary Newsom testified for the first bill and Deena Christian for the second.
The parents will return to testify before a House committee in two weeks.
My
sources for this story were the Knoxville News Sentinel and WBIR,
Knoxville's NBC station. I also used my own observations at the trials I
attended or watched by live stream.
Monday, December 23, 2013
The Christian-Newsom Torture-Murder Case: A Synopsis
GUEST ENTRY from DAVID in TENNESSEE!
On Saturday night, January 6, 2007, Channon Christian, 21, and Christopher Newsom, 23, were carjacked from the Washington Ridge Apartments in Knoxville, Tennessee. They were taken to a house on Chipman Street about three and a half miles away.
Over the next several hours, Christian and Newsom were both raped, tortured, and murdered. Chris Newsom was dragged by a dog leash around his neck to a railroad track several hundred yards from the Chipman Street house. He was naked from the waist down and his hands were tied behind his back. Chris' face was wrapped in a sweatshirt and his mouth was gagged with his own socks, His bare feet were bound. He had been raped with "an object." and by unknown males. At the track, Newsom was shot three times, only the last was fatal. His body was set on fire, which destroyed the DNA evidence and made it impossible to identify which of the killers raped him.
Mary Newsom, Chris' mother, wanted to see the body. The police would not let her. She put her arms around the body bag.
Channon Christian's body was found in the house of Lemaricus Davidson, who is considered the ringleader of those involved. The five feet, eight inches tall Channon Christian was "crammed," according to the medical examiner in a garbage can. She was "hog-tied" with a plastic bag over her head. DNA evidence showed she had been raped vaginally and anally. Semen from Davidson's half-brother was found in her mouth. Her vaginal area had been beaten bloody, either kicked or by something used as a club. Bleach had been sprayed down her throat in an attempt to destroy DNA.
Channon Christian's Toyota 4Runner was found abandoned in the general area. It had been wiped down. However, an envelope was found with a fingerprint. When run through the Automated Fingerprint Identification System (AFIS) database, it belonged to Davidson. This broke the case.
Without this one fingerprint, the murders might be unsolved to this day.
Four people were arrested for the torture-murders. They were Davidson, his half-brother Letalvis Cobbins, George Thomas, and Vanessa Coleman, the lone female defendant. A fifth, Eric Boyd, was charged in federal court as an accessory for aiding Davidson after the crime.
According to Cobbins, Boyd provided the vehicle and took part in the carjacking. Boyd was not charged in the murders because he could not be placed in the Chipman Street house.
The crime was called a "robbery" and a "random" event. However, the only things stolen were items in Channon's purse which were found in Coleman's possession. The Toyota was not kept even though it had a market value of $15,000 according to Channon's father, Gary Christian, who worked at a Toyota dealership. Nor did they try to ransom the victims whom the perpetrators thought were rich.
Here is Knoxville News Sentinel reporter Jamis Satterfield's account of what she thinks happened on Chipman Street. Satterfield believes Boyd raped Chris and that Coleman beat Channon's private parts. I agree with her on these points. I disagree when she writes of it as a "random carjacking." "Random" means it was accidental. The whole affair was very deliberate and as mentioned above, the car was not kept by the killers.
Eric Boyd was convicted in 2008 as an accessory and sentenced to 18 years in federal prison.
Cobbins was convicted in August of 2009 and sentenced to life without parole. Davidson was convicted on October 28, 2009 and sentenced to death. Also in 2009, George Thomas was convicted and sentenced to life without parole.
In 2010, Vanessa Coleman was acquitted of all charges regarding Christopher Newsom and of Channon Christian's murder. She was convicted of 17 facilitation charges against Christian and sentenced to 53 years.
I was in the courtroom for three days of Vanessa Coleman's trial. It seemed to me that some of the female jurors felt sorry for Coleman. At the time, jurors were allowed to ask questions and I saw some pro-defense questions during police testimony. Coleman kept a journal and had some entries for the weekend of the murders. She wrote in part:
"Lets talk about adventures! I've had one HELL OF AN ADVENTURE since I've been in the big T.N.HA! HA!"
The jurors had no questions about Coleman's diary.
In 2011, it was revealed that Richard Baumgartner, who presided over all four state trials, had been using illegal prescription drugs obtained from a probationer in his own court. He had used drugs during the Christian-Newsom trials.
Judge Jon Kerry Blackwood, who replaced Baumgartner, overturned all four verdicts and said they must be retried.
The Knoxville District Attorney General appealed to the Tennessee Supreme Court and another judge, Walter Kurtz, ruled the Davidson and Cobbins verdicts would stand because of the DNA evidence. Also, Cobbins had testified. Judge Kurtz ordered new a new trial for George Thomas.
The retrial for Coleman had not been contested and took place in November of 2012 with Blackwood presiding. This time Coleman was convicted on 13 of 17 counts and was sentenced to 35 years in prison, somewhat less than the first time.
She will be up for parole around five years from now.
George Thomas was convicted for a second time on May 17, 2013. This time Thomas received a sentence of life with the possibility of parole. By law, he must serve at least 51 years.
For the parents of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom, the second Thomas verdict made seven trials and over 300 court appearances.
Let us hope the case is over.
David in TN
David in TN
Thursday, August 29, 2013
Christian-Newsom Murders Documentary: Forever Changed
Last week, a post appeared in The Blaze.com titled A Story That Has To Be Told, about Gail and David Witt's struggle to complete their documentary, Forever Changed.
Forever Changed which began production in 2010, details the brutal murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom and the long road to justice for these victims. It's a great read and I highly recommend it. The documentary is expected to be completed by the end of 2013.
Forever Changed Project Facebook Page
T&T's Trial Coverage
Channon Christian & Christopher Newsom Facebook Group Page
Calls For Justice Trial Coverage
Forever Changed which began production in 2010, details the brutal murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom and the long road to justice for these victims. It's a great read and I highly recommend it. The documentary is expected to be completed by the end of 2013.
Forever Changed Project Facebook Page
T&T's Trial Coverage
Channon Christian & Christopher Newsom Facebook Group Page
Calls For Justice Trial Coverage
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Thomas Convicted For Second Time In Christian-Newsom Torture-Murders
Christopher Newsom, Channon Christian, date unknown.
On Friday, May 17, George Thomas was convicted for the second time in the January 2007 torture-murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom.
For the victim's families, this made seven trials and over 300 court appearances.
A Davidson County (Nashville) jury found Thomas guilty on all counts, the same as in Thomas' previous trial in 2009. The jurors were unaware that George Thomas had been convicted of the same crimes in 2009.
On the same afternoon, the panel of six men and six women gave Thomas a sentence of life with the possibility of parole. The previous conviction saw a sentence of life without parole. By law, he cannot come up for parole until after serving 51 years. With six years to his credit, Thomas would be 75 years old.
On June 4, there will be a sentencing hearing on the lesser charges and more can be added to the sentence.
Thomas defense attorneys were much more aggressive than in 2009. They argued for his innocence on the grounds of no DNA or fingerprint evidence against him.
Lemaricus Davidson, the ringleader, was sentenced to death. Letalvis Cobbins is serving life without parole. Judge Walter Kurtz rejected new trials for these two because of overwhelming DNA evidence tying them to the rape and murder of Channon Christian.
Attorneys for Davidson and Cobbins are appealing but most observers think their convictions will stand.
The lone female defendant, Vanessa Coleman, was convicted of facilitation for the second time last November. Her sentence was 35 years, down from 53 after her first trial.
A fifth man, Eric Boyd, has always been suspected to of taking part in the carjacking and other crimes. Boyd was clever enough not to admit being in the Chipman Street house and there was no forensic evidence against him.
Boyd was convicted in 2008 in federal court as an accessory and sentenced to 18 years.
Thomas and Cobbins in police interviews said Boyd participated in the carjacking but these statements could not be used in court unless they took the stand. The families believe Boyd got away with murder.
Both the Christians and Newsoms vow to attend any more proceedings in this horrific case.
Here is a link from WATE with several videos of the reaction of family members to the verdict and another from WBIR.
David in TN
George Thomas at his retrial.
Friday, May 17, 2013
Cristian-Newsom Torture-Murders - Notes from the George Thomas Retrial
GUEST ENTRY FROM David In Tennessee!
UPDATE: Verdict came in for Thomas around 9:30 AM PT Guilty on all counts This is a sweep for the prosecution. Sprocket
May 13th, 2013
I arrived in the courtroom at 9 am on Monday, May 13, for the retrial of George Thomas for his part in the torture-murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom in January 2007.
Thomas was convicted on all counts in 2009, but the verdict was overturned because of the criminal behavior of former judge Richard Baumgartner. Judge Walter Kurtz ruled that Thomas had to be retried because he could not act as 13th juror without hearing the testimony.
Before opening statements, Judge Kurtz told the jury they would be general outlines of the respective cases. The prosecution opening by Deputy Attorney General for Knox County, Takisha Fitzgerald fit this description. The opening by defense attorney Stephen Ross Johnson went over an hour and was like a closing argument, rather than an opening.
The judge admonished Johnson toward the end, but allowed him to go on.
Throughout the trial, the defense attorneys have come on far stronger than in Thomas' first trial.
In her opening, Fitzgerald referred to what Thomas said to detective Nevil Norman as "F*** that girl, she don't mean nothing to me!" Johnson, however, gave Norman's full account: "F*** that white girl, she don't mean nothing to me!"
Johnson then accused the prosecutor of trying to "appeal to your emotions." Actually, the prosecutor played down the racial aspect of the statement, while Johnson emphasized it.
The defense attorney used a power point demonstration to attack criminal responsibility as it applied to Thomas. Again, much like in a closing argument.
I counted 14 people present who were friends and family of the victims. There were about 30 spectators on average on Monday. There were up to 40 at times on Tuesday in a courtroom that would hold well over a hundred people. On the other hand, everybody in Knoxville is aware of this case and trial.
On Tuesday morning I was in line waiting to go in and a man and woman in their twenties were behind me. They weren't sure they were at the right courtroom and asked a sheriff's deputy (you had to empty your pockets a second time to see the trial) "It's not that big one, is it?" The deputy answered, "Yes it is." They went in another courtroom.
Perhaps the key witness in Vanessa Coleman's trial was Xavier Jenkins, who worked at a waste treatment agency next to the Chipman Street house. Jenkins saw four black males in Channon Christian's Toyota 4Runner. The defense cross-examined him very aggressively but couldn't dent Jenkins" testimony.
In this trial, the defense asked how he could tell it was four black males, but Jenkins easily answered, saying in effect, as a black man myself I can tell.
The defense did not cross several of the witnesses, especially the fingerprint and DNA specialists. Neither were found belonging to Thomas and they were claiming Thomas was not involved with what happened to the victims.
The mothers of Channon and Chris testified as they have in six previous trials. The defense had no questions for them.
Throughout you heard the name Eric Boyd and many have wondered why Boyd was not charged. It appears he provided the "wheels" for the carjacking. The reason? Boyd was clever enough not to admit to being in the Chipman house.
Each of the other suspects were read Miranda warnings and told they did not have to speak to the police, but insisted on doing so without a lawyer. Each of them tried to blame it on the others. Their police interviews were vague and not informative anyway.
Whenever Thomas came into the courtroom from a holding cell (before the jury is brought in) he would have his hands clasped behind his back. There were no handcuffs on his hands.
Thomas had an air of complete indifference sitting at the defense table. He was the same way in police interviews played in court, with a sneering dismissive tone.
Daphne Sutton testified on Tuesday. Last November I wrote that she looked and dressed like a poor relation of the Kardashian sisters. This time Sutton was dressed in a plain fashion.
Daphne Sutton described George Thomas as being in the house just like the others. More people were in the courtroom during Sutton's testimony.
On cross, defense attorney Tom Dillard spent a fair amount of time on cross, but was not near as aggressive as Vanessa Coleman's attorney, Ted Lavitt.
After a cell phone expert testified, court was adjourned for Tuesday.
Speaking of cell phones, the prosecution was able to show that Lemaricus Davidson, the ringleader, allowed Thomas to use his cell phone to call Stacey Lawson, Thomas' girlfriend, back in Kentucky.
The inference is that Davidson would not allow someone to use his phone who was not involved in what was going on.
Because of family obligations, I had to go back home after Tuesday's session.
The prosecution finished their case on Wednesday. Thomas declined to testify and the defense rested without calling any witnesses. Thursday morning saw closing arguments. The jury was given the case Thursday afternoon.
David in TN
UPDATE: Verdict came in for Thomas around 9:30 AM PT Guilty on all counts This is a sweep for the prosecution. Sprocket
May 13th, 2013
I arrived in the courtroom at 9 am on Monday, May 13, for the retrial of George Thomas for his part in the torture-murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom in January 2007.
Thomas was convicted on all counts in 2009, but the verdict was overturned because of the criminal behavior of former judge Richard Baumgartner. Judge Walter Kurtz ruled that Thomas had to be retried because he could not act as 13th juror without hearing the testimony.
Before opening statements, Judge Kurtz told the jury they would be general outlines of the respective cases. The prosecution opening by Deputy Attorney General for Knox County, Takisha Fitzgerald fit this description. The opening by defense attorney Stephen Ross Johnson went over an hour and was like a closing argument, rather than an opening.
The judge admonished Johnson toward the end, but allowed him to go on.
Throughout the trial, the defense attorneys have come on far stronger than in Thomas' first trial.
In her opening, Fitzgerald referred to what Thomas said to detective Nevil Norman as "F*** that girl, she don't mean nothing to me!" Johnson, however, gave Norman's full account: "F*** that white girl, she don't mean nothing to me!"
Johnson then accused the prosecutor of trying to "appeal to your emotions." Actually, the prosecutor played down the racial aspect of the statement, while Johnson emphasized it.
The defense attorney used a power point demonstration to attack criminal responsibility as it applied to Thomas. Again, much like in a closing argument.
I counted 14 people present who were friends and family of the victims. There were about 30 spectators on average on Monday. There were up to 40 at times on Tuesday in a courtroom that would hold well over a hundred people. On the other hand, everybody in Knoxville is aware of this case and trial.
On Tuesday morning I was in line waiting to go in and a man and woman in their twenties were behind me. They weren't sure they were at the right courtroom and asked a sheriff's deputy (you had to empty your pockets a second time to see the trial) "It's not that big one, is it?" The deputy answered, "Yes it is." They went in another courtroom.
Perhaps the key witness in Vanessa Coleman's trial was Xavier Jenkins, who worked at a waste treatment agency next to the Chipman Street house. Jenkins saw four black males in Channon Christian's Toyota 4Runner. The defense cross-examined him very aggressively but couldn't dent Jenkins" testimony.
In this trial, the defense asked how he could tell it was four black males, but Jenkins easily answered, saying in effect, as a black man myself I can tell.
The defense did not cross several of the witnesses, especially the fingerprint and DNA specialists. Neither were found belonging to Thomas and they were claiming Thomas was not involved with what happened to the victims.
The mothers of Channon and Chris testified as they have in six previous trials. The defense had no questions for them.
Throughout you heard the name Eric Boyd and many have wondered why Boyd was not charged. It appears he provided the "wheels" for the carjacking. The reason? Boyd was clever enough not to admit to being in the Chipman house.
Each of the other suspects were read Miranda warnings and told they did not have to speak to the police, but insisted on doing so without a lawyer. Each of them tried to blame it on the others. Their police interviews were vague and not informative anyway.
Whenever Thomas came into the courtroom from a holding cell (before the jury is brought in) he would have his hands clasped behind his back. There were no handcuffs on his hands.
Thomas had an air of complete indifference sitting at the defense table. He was the same way in police interviews played in court, with a sneering dismissive tone.
Daphne Sutton testified on Tuesday. Last November I wrote that she looked and dressed like a poor relation of the Kardashian sisters. This time Sutton was dressed in a plain fashion.
Daphne Sutton described George Thomas as being in the house just like the others. More people were in the courtroom during Sutton's testimony.
On cross, defense attorney Tom Dillard spent a fair amount of time on cross, but was not near as aggressive as Vanessa Coleman's attorney, Ted Lavitt.
After a cell phone expert testified, court was adjourned for Tuesday.
Speaking of cell phones, the prosecution was able to show that Lemaricus Davidson, the ringleader, allowed Thomas to use his cell phone to call Stacey Lawson, Thomas' girlfriend, back in Kentucky.
The inference is that Davidson would not allow someone to use his phone who was not involved in what was going on.
Because of family obligations, I had to go back home after Tuesday's session.
The prosecution finished their case on Wednesday. Thomas declined to testify and the defense rested without calling any witnesses. Thursday morning saw closing arguments. The jury was given the case Thursday afternoon.
David in TN
Saturday, May 11, 2013
Christian-Newsom Torture-Murder Case: George Thomas Retrial Set to Begin
GUEST ENTRY FROM DAVID IN TENNESSEE!
On Friday, May 10th, sixteen jurors were selected for the retrial of George Thomas for his part in the torture-murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom.
Judge Walter Kurtz announced that 12 will be chosen by lot to deliberate at trial's end.
Back in 2009, I wrote an account of the crime for T&T.
The jury panel is made up of three white women, five black women, and eight white men. The trial is set to begin Monday, May 13th.
The jurors will travel by bus from Nashville to Knoxville over the weekend. They will be sequestered in a Knoxville hotel and be transported together to court. This has been the procedure in the previous trials in this case.
George Thomas was convicted on all counts in 2009, but was granted a new trial because the judge in his first trial, Richard Baumgartner, was forced from the bench and is now serving a six-month sentence in federal prison.
The lone female defendant, Vanessa Coleman, was convicted of the facilitation of Channon Christian's rape and murder for the second time last November. The other two defendants, Letalvis Cobbins and Lemaricus Davidson, were denied new trials due to extensive DNA evidence against them.
There was no DNA linking Thomas to the crimes, but he admitted to being present in the Chipman Street house the entire time. Judge Kurtz decided he could not act as 13th juror without seeing the testimony and ordered a retrial for George Thomas.
The same prosecution team of Takisha Fitgerald and Leland Price that has handled all the trials in this case will be retrying Thomas. The defense team is led by Tom Lillard, with co-counsel is Stephen Ross Johnson. They were appointed by Judge Richard Baumgartner and represented Thomas in his first trial.
I will be traveling to Knoxville on Sunday to cover the first two days of the trial.
David in TN
CHRISTIAN NEWSOM MURDERS QUICK LINKS TO ALL T&T STORIES
Knox News Jury Story
On Friday, May 10th, sixteen jurors were selected for the retrial of George Thomas for his part in the torture-murders of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom.
Judge Walter Kurtz announced that 12 will be chosen by lot to deliberate at trial's end.
Back in 2009, I wrote an account of the crime for T&T.
The jury panel is made up of three white women, five black women, and eight white men. The trial is set to begin Monday, May 13th.
The jurors will travel by bus from Nashville to Knoxville over the weekend. They will be sequestered in a Knoxville hotel and be transported together to court. This has been the procedure in the previous trials in this case.
George Thomas was convicted on all counts in 2009, but was granted a new trial because the judge in his first trial, Richard Baumgartner, was forced from the bench and is now serving a six-month sentence in federal prison.
The lone female defendant, Vanessa Coleman, was convicted of the facilitation of Channon Christian's rape and murder for the second time last November. The other two defendants, Letalvis Cobbins and Lemaricus Davidson, were denied new trials due to extensive DNA evidence against them.
There was no DNA linking Thomas to the crimes, but he admitted to being present in the Chipman Street house the entire time. Judge Kurtz decided he could not act as 13th juror without seeing the testimony and ordered a retrial for George Thomas.
The same prosecution team of Takisha Fitgerald and Leland Price that has handled all the trials in this case will be retrying Thomas. The defense team is led by Tom Lillard, with co-counsel is Stephen Ross Johnson. They were appointed by Judge Richard Baumgartner and represented Thomas in his first trial.
I will be traveling to Knoxville on Sunday to cover the first two days of the trial.
David in TN
CHRISTIAN NEWSOM MURDERS QUICK LINKS TO ALL T&T STORIES
Knox News Jury Story
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











